DryMind

Ad hominem

Source

Discusion of an idea or argument should be done completely independent of who or where it came from

Violations of this:

  • Questioning the motivation: "You are paid to say that"
  • Abuse: "You are a Nazi"
  • Tu Quoque: "... but you do not follow it yourself."
    • Inability to follow a principle does not nullify the principle itself.
  • Guilt by association: "This is exactly what Nazi's did."
    • Just because our argument aligns with a malefactor, does not mean all our arguments are invalid. Inorder to prove otherwise, one have to show that deplorable arguments of the malefactor can be derived from this.
Ad hominem